ATAZ wrote:
I like the idea of minimum weight for this class. Good ET's are a combination of power, weight, prop, experience etc so maybe we can have some sort of calculation between say two factors. Divide them into a percentage and have a class tolerance. So if I'm 1550 with a 225 and someone else is 1650 with a 200... I should add some weight to keep us with in competitive specs. How the numbers are corrected and agreed upon would take some time to figure out. Just an idea 225/1550 is 14.5% where as 200/1650 is 12.1% and we agree on a 2% variance. So 225/1595 14.1%, therefor I would have to add roughly 45lbs to keep things more even. Then the rest comes down to hull design, prop, driver etc. it does make things a little more complicated but definitely gives the average lake boat better odds against a very competitive formula drag boat.
Your post is exactly what this class needs. An open mind for the overall competition and how balanced it should become (eventually one day
A boat with a 250lb weight advantage if all power is the same has no chance if all abilities are equal. 1550lb was just thrown out there guys to get things started. The "AVERAGE" boat will be extremely close to that I promise. 500lbs for a wet engine, 38lbs for a battery, jackplate rigging etc etc. Seats and hull all add up and with the average driver weight of 200lb you aren't far off.
This is a tough thing to swallow and some will need to add weight yes but we have to try (or should) to level the playing field here. I like Greg and consider him a good friend but I'd like to see a rules package that lends itself to a better chance of others winning. I remember weight a Charger 18' DL with a Johnson 200 and full seats and from what I remember it was 1420lb without a driver.
The other route to take is to simply just throw a winning penalty at Greg's FORMULA entry but that is not what is best for the class.
Try to think like ATAZ here and think from above without your own boat in mind and think about the class health and perception. There will never be 100% satisfaction here but let's try for open dialogue on what is at least acceptable