Chummy wrote:
I have two suggestions:
1. My point was 15' boat cant hold as much weight as a 20' boat, sitting still or under way, the laws of physics wont allow it, so maybe a new rule should be implied... a minimum length boat. ODBA has that rule, not sure about DSRA, this would keep this issue from arising again.
2. Stick to women your own age.
Not sure the reason for your (2)
As for (1) - I think you may be mislead about this conversation or what the weekend consisted of. The minimum length rule was removed with Mike's boat in mind as I believe it was set at 15 or 16' in length previous years ???? Not sure . No one even asked Mike to put a single lb of weight in his boat for Gravenhurst although it was suggested that he could run full of fuel (he designed the boat with that tank in it so why not) . Not once not ever. At least not when I was around. It was mentioned by a few that maybe he should run a larger pitch prop to compensate for the extremely low weight he was at when we weighed him 1060lbs possibly I don't remember.
Also keep in mind that Mike was aware he was an "experiment" for any class it was decided he would run in. He was originally slated to run in our FORMULA class but he decided on a different powerhead I guess.
No one here said he should put 500lbs of weight in his boat or else ...... That is what this discussion is about.
The simple facts are this and have always been this.
There have been a set of rules posted. Those set of rules have a small few that voted and those small few all voted in favour. Not one vote is against the rules as of 5min ago.
We have always tried to fit Mike and his Allison in to some class and did so. Mike and I discussed this experiment many times and it was never a yes or a no. It was a "let's see how it goes".
We have to have some set of guidelines and to be honest the rules we do have are so small it's a joke. . . 12" miss allowed. Allison RR's allowed. Any engine mods besides true Drag/S3000 powerheads limited to 150lbs of compression. Any gasoline allowed.
And a simple well known 1550lbs min because we have some heavyweight boats that have decided to be regulars and made their voice heard so it is 1550. . . 10lbs heavier than the 260 std drag type weights out there.
Let's try and see what we can do to make this work as its great to have the boats but not at the cost of the work that's been done to date.
Pat's idea seems on the right track and it's a good one. I'd only recalculate based on the average lengths of the boats from Gravenhurst excluding Mike's (17'8" to 19'7)
Boomer is a different case all together. There are rules and that should really be just that. He was right there to begin with and had a great showing.